What are the Pros and Cons of Recycled Wood Flooring?

Are they worth it?

Choosing flooring for your home may seem less eco-friendly than installing solar panels or a heat pump, yet recycled wood floors have many environmental benefits. And there is a host of species and styles to choose from parquet to plank flooring and chevron.  When buildings are demolished or remodelled, timber can be salvaged and re-purposed instead of dumped in landfill sites. Recycled wood flooring often comes from old barns, country houses, factories and mills. The specification is important - where it comes from and how old it is.

Reclaimed flooring

Pros of Using Recycled Wood Flooring

There are multiple benefits to choosing recycled wood flooring:-

Eco-friendly:

Reclaimed wood reduces the demand for newly harvested timber. Fewer trees need to be chopped down to make new wood flooring. One of the major concerns with building with wood is deforestation. “If not managed sustainably, timber extraction for construction process can destroy forests vital for carbon sequestration, biodiversity and maintaining ecological balance,” warns Green Match, a website for green energy solutions. Recycled wood promotes recycling, leading to less deforestation and waste. It also minimises energy used in processing new wood, decreasing the carbon footprint of the floor.

Durability

Recycled wood often comes from trees harvested decades ago when they were mature. This naturally grown wood is typically denser and more durable than many types of commercially grown timber available today. “Age gives reclaimed timber more strength and durability,” states the Reclaimed Flooring Company, adding: “Wood over 100 years old is particularly suitable for high-traffic areas due to its tight-grain, making it resistant and hard-wearing.” If the building or barn from which the recycled timber is salvaged from is centuries old, it may come from ancient forests, making it ideal for flooring. Reclaimed timber has “had time to expand and contract with age, making it less susceptible to warping and cracking,” explains the British Wood Flooring Company.

Unique aesthetic:

Reclaimed wood often has a distinctive, rustic appearance that new wood can’t replicate. Each plank has its own rich history, often featuring knots and nail holes that add character and interest to the finished floor. As the British Wood Flooring Company states its Renaissance Oak Floors “offer natural original features such as shakes, splits and pippy knot details” that occurred over time. There may also be colour variation, reflecting its “lived experience.”

Cost savings & versatility

The price of new timber is on the rise. Reclaimed timber can be a cost-effective flooring solution, especially when sourced locally from demolition sites. The range of reclaimed flooring includes engineered boards as well as solid wood flooring. According to the British Wood Flooring Company, reclaimed wooden floors can be fully compatible with under floor heating systems and can be treated for use in wet areas such as kitchens and bathrooms. However, it is always advisable to check with suppliers.

Cons of Using Recycled Wood

While reclaimed wood flooring has many benefits, there are some downsides.

Installation challenges

Timber from a salvage yard or demolition project will require additional preparation before installation, such as removing old nails and screws. The work to clean and prepare recycled wood for use adds to the labour cost. Chemical contamination is another factor to consider. Paint, varnish, glue or fire retardant may have been added to the wood. However companies that specialise in reclaimed wood flooring do this preparation work, so there is less worry about potential defects.

Expertise required

Working with reclaimed wood flooring requires detailed knowledge to ensure a successful outcome. Old wood can harbour mould or insects that can quickly spread from one plank to another. The timber must be carefully inspected for infestation to ensure it’s safe to reuse. Some reclaimed wood floor suppliers kiln-dry their timber to kill insects while others may spray it with highly volatile and toxic chemicals. Check your supplier’s environmental credentials to ensure they keep VOCs to a minimum.

Variable quality

The quality of reclaimed wood can be variable. It may come with imperfections such as signs of wear and tear and there is likely to be significant colour variation. Depending on how you choose to finish the wood flooring (hard wax oil, traditional wax or lacquer), it may be possible to even out the tone of the floor, but it won’t be as uniform as pre-finished new wood. If you opt for reclaimed wood, it’s best to embrace this colour variation as part of its charm rather than combat it, suggest suppliers.

Limited availability

Scarcity can be another downside of reclaimed wood, partly due to its popularity. “It can be downright difficult to find,” states Renaissance Hardwood Floors. “It may take many weeks or months to source the wood for your project, so you’ll need to be patient during the process. If you’re on a tight time schedule, reclaimed wood might not be a practical option for you.” When ordering reclaimed wood, check the amount available on the delivery date will cover the square footage of your floor. A different batch will contain different timber.

Compatibility issues

Recycled wood might not always be compatible with modern building materials or techniques. This can lead to challenges in achieving a uniform look or ensuring the structural integrity of the renovation. Builders will need to carefully assess and sometimes adapt their plans to incorporate the reclaimed material effectively. .

Higher costs

While upcycled products are usually cheaper than new ones, the opposite can be true when it comes to reclaimed flooring. “The process of sourcing, salvaging and preparing reclaimed wood can be labour intensive,” explains Renaissance Hardwood Floors. However, the British Wood Flooring Company states reclaimed wood is often a more cost-effective solution than newly harvested wood.

Recycling wood is vitally important for creating a healthier, more environmentally friendly planet. Choosing reclaimed wood flooring can help to save forests and extends the lifecycle of a natural resource. Coupled with being eco-friendly, using reclaimed wood makes a statement. “Your kitchen floor could once have been the walls of a French railway station or your wall cladding the beams from a barn or warehouse,” explains the Reclaimed Flooring Company. While there are some downsides to consider, reclaimed wood flooring oozes character and should last a lifetime.